Gandalf die alone on a mountain top high above Moria after beating ‘Fred’ the Balrog. Wherein in the story walk this occasion occur?

Q: as soon as Does Gandalf Die?

ANSWER: countless readers space confused about just precisely where Gandalf is stated to die in The mr of the Rings. It is Gandalf’s fatality that precedes the event where that turns into “Gandalf the White”, although the is not specifically a metamophosis.

You are watching: How did gandalf end up on top of a mountain

In the Fellowship the the Ring chapter “The leg of Khazad-dum” Gandalf confronts a terror that the ancient world, a Balrog of Morgoth, in Moria. The Balrog is a creature like Gandalf, a previous member that the order of the Ainur, the “oldest” that all developed beings. The Balrog is the critical remnant that the demonic servants that Morgoth from the first Age. That had, Tolkien says in the assorted texts, fled indigenous the loss of Morgoth’s forces in Beleriand and also hidden chin deep under the Misty Mountains.

Tolkien’s concept of what a Balrog was had changed from his faster fiction. In his mythology because that England, The book of lost Tales, Tolkien had defined Balrogs as terrible monsters that rode into fight on or in metal dragons. They to be a type of hefty cavalry among evil forces and there were maybe a thousand of them. They to be an elite army force qualified of wreaking great havoc and destruction upon your foes, Elves and Men.

As Tolkien adjusted his story into brand-new mythological frameworks he carried the Balrogs front in an ambiguous fashion. They were not major characters in his stories, return he constantly intended to rewrite “The loss of Gondolin” in i beg your pardon Glorfindel, an Elf lord, sacrificed himself and slew a Balrog. At least one other Balrog was to dice in the story together well: Gothmog, lord of Balrogs.

As Tolkien wrote around the Balrog of Moria pull close Gandalf top top the bridge of Khazad-dum the author realized the his traditional Balrogs were not really sufficiently an effective to difficulty someone favor Gandalf. Therefore Tolkien provided his work on The lord of the Rings come flesh out some brand-new details about Balrogs, converting them from bred or manufactured shock troops right into a small variety of demonic beings who wielded an excellent power.

The Balrog that Moria thus came to be an adversary practically as an effective as Sauron himself, yet it posed a much more immediate danger to Frodo and also the Fellowship of the Ring. Hence, Gandalf ensured that he and he alone faced the Balrog straight by place himself between his companions and the Balrog. By now in the story Tolkien has already subtly hinted to the reader that neither Gandalf nor the Balrog are conveniently slain; in a previous scene Gandalf had used his strength to collapse component of the mountain on height of the Balrog, and the force of the devastation was powerful enough to knock Gandalf under a long stairway. Together a loss should have actually killed or seriously injured a typical man but Gandalf simply stood up and also dusted himself.

Hence, when Gandalf damaged the bridge over the chasm that may have actually seemed to inattentive readers that he was creating an impassable barrier for the Balrog, which dropped off the crumbling the bridge into the chasm. The Balrog lashed out v his whip come entangle Gandalf, who quickly slid follow me the bridge and fell into the chasm, crying together he went “fly, girlfriend fools!”.

When one pauses to take into consideration the details that this scene, some questions around what is keep going occur. For example, some readers have actually asked why Gandalf has time to say anything at all if the fallout’s Balrog’s whip has actually wrapped itself around Gandalf’s legs. The not-so-obvious price is the Tolkien is implying the instance is no unfolding precisely as it would if, say, a troll had fallen off the bridge and had somehow managed to entangle a mere male with a whip.

Rather, both the Balrog and Gandalf are beings of great power and strength. Yet the Balrog has likewise manifested itself as a “creature that flame and also shadow”. It is clearly not incorporated in a body of flesh and also bone, therefore one need to ask if the Balrog was actually heavy, in the feeling of gift dense and also massive like a vast cave troll. Gandalf, too, has additionally previously prove superhuman capabilities (such as lightly delivering Frodo and also moving quickly; breaking a branch off a tree during a battle; dealing with four or 5 Nazgul in a night-long conflict).

Thus, the leader is enabled to infer the Gandalf was able to briefly assistance himself and quite more than likely the Balrog together he grasped the crumbling edge of the bridge, not regardless of gravity and also natural laws of physics yet simply because of both his and also the Balrog’s one-of-a-kind natures.

Later in the story Gandalf defines his descent into the chasm together a lengthy fall. The message does not show at what rate Gandalf and also the Balrog fell however Gandalf states that he hews in ~ his foe with his sword and that the Balrog’s fire envelops him. When people ask why the autumn did no kill Gandalf and also the Balrog, the logical answer is that they either might not be so easily killed or rather they were able to sluggish their descent.

Gandalf’s battle lasted for 11 days. In fact, once the Fellowship that the Ring were preparing to leaving Lothlorien Haldir the Elf report to Frodo: “The Dimrill Dale is full of vapour and clouds the smoke, and also the mountains are troubled. There are noises in the deeps the the earth….” This is supposedly a referral to the rage of the fight between Gandalf and the Balrog.

According come Gandalf’s account of the fight he and the Balrog eventually arised on a high peak of the mountain. Castle inflicted mortal wounds on each other. The Balrog’s dice or lifeless body dropped from the mountaintop and smote the side of the mountain further down (apparently dense enough come crush a big portion of the mountain). Gandalf himself died on the mountain top.

His spirit, according to a letter Tolkien later wrote, departed indigenous the world and also returned come Iluvatar, who sent Gandalf back with increased power and authority. Gandalf’s revived body was recovered indigenous the top by Gwaihir, who had been sent out by Galadriel. Gwaihir take it Gandalf to Lothlorien where the Elves gave him white robes. Gandalf additionally acquired or made a new staff in Lothlorien. From this time front he was Gandalf the White.

See more: Fold Like A Cheap Suit Meaning, Fold Like A Cheap Suitcase Idiom, Proverb

There has actually been dispute over even if it is Gandalf might have passed away again one of two people in fight or by some other means. That is a meaningless debate due to the fact that Gandalf never again encounters anything equivalent to a Balrog. ~ the battle of the Ring Gandalf takes ship through Elrond, Frodo, Bilbo, and many Elves and he leaves starrkingschool.net forever. In a sense Gandalf’s exit is prefer a second death since the Elves accurate depart indigenous starrkingschool.net and also pass to a brand-new world whereby they room to continue to be until the end of Time.

Learn much more about Gandalf here …

Where walk Gandalf Live?

What was the source of Gandalf’s Fireworks?

How much Power walk Gandalf Have?

Why walk Gandalf Say, “Fly girlfriend Fools”?

How long Did Gandalf and also the Balrog Fall?

Did Gandalf Really dice after killing the Balrog?

How did Gandalf kill the Balrog that Moria?

How does Gandalf get His employee Back?

Why go Gandalf leave Bilbo and the Dwarves in The Hobbit?

Could the lord of the Nazgûl Have defeated Gandalf?

# # #

Have you check out our other Tolkien and also starrkingschool.net Questions and Answers articles?