Do you agree through the speaker in "Mending Wall"? In the poem, "Mending Wall", written by Robert Frost, the speaker says that he wants to rest the wall. Carry out you agree with him?
Who space the experts?Our certified Educators are genuine professors, teachers, and also scholars who usage their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go with a rigorous applications process, and every prize they submit is reviewed by ours in-house editorial team.

You are watching: What would the speaker in mending wall do if he could



I, too, discovered this component of the city ironic in that the narrator of the poem seems to be poking funny (being sarcastic) about the reality that the ar keeps repair the wall. A wall surface is just a barrier that really cannot keep people off of each others" property, if...


Start your 48-hour totally free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy starrkingschool.net ad-free and cancel anytime.


I, too, uncovered this component of the poem ironic in the the narrator the the poem seems to be poking fun (being sarcastic) about the reality that the neighbor keeps mending the wall. A wall surface is just a barrier that really cannot keep world off of each others" property, if one is realistic about it. One can climb end the wall, walk roughly it in some instances, etc. I think among Frost"s point out is that "walls" are internal, realistically. They space symbols that stand for the people we placed up in ourselves.


approved by starrkingschool.net Editorial Team

amy-lepore
Educator due to the fact that 2005

3,503 answers


| Certified education
web page Citation

Share connect
I execute agree. Wall surfaces make good neighbors in the what is and also should it is in private have the right to remain that way. The wall surface is tho low sufficient that the neigbors can converse over the height of it and additionally work together yearly to preserve it"s integrity. Over there are just a select couple of people whom i would want to disclose whatever to--everyone else is a familiar acquaintance to whom ns speak and also disclose just the parts of my life I want them come know.


authorized by starrkingschool.net Editorial Team

Reuben lindsay
Educator since 2005

1,774 answers


| Certified educator
page Citation

Share link
The famed quote indigenous this poem has been mentioned above "good fences make an excellent neighbors." However, this is one ironic statement. The narrator is an important of his neighbor for constantly repairing the wall surface that keeps people out. Frost to be commenting ~ above society"s tendency to alienate others, to it is in wary that the unknown, and also thus to reason the failure in communities. I carry out agree v him. We close ourselves off so much from each other that we often turn away much needed support. How wonderful would the civilization be if we didn"t have actually "borders"?


approved by starrkingschool.net Editorial Team

linda-allen
Educator because 2004

2,115 answers


| Certified education
page Citation

Share link
Well, the speaker doesn"t exactly want the wall down:"Something...wants that down."

The poem reflects two neighbours coming together for the annualrebuilding that the wall surface between your properties. Return thespeaker appears dubious around what function the wall has, the ishe who initiates the rebuilding ("I permit myneighbour know...") and also doing irregular repairs on his owninitiative ("I have come after them and made repair").But he likewise dismisses the rebuilding as "just another kind ofoutdoor game." Why does the play?

I think the prize is that while he might feel the wallshould it is in unnecessary, he additionally needs to keep his neighbourat a distance. He teases the man, but is wary that him and cannotunderstand his clinging come "his father"s saying" around goodneighbours needing great fences. Near the end, the narrator slipsinto a defensive tone,

I check out him thereBringing a stone grasped steady by the topIn each hand, favor an old-stone savage armed.He move in darkness as it appears to me,Not the woods only and also the shade of trees

This evokes the original role of walls, from the Garden ofEden onward, to store "darkness" outside, away from humancivilization.

To sum up, nature and also growth work versus walls, however theever-present hazard from the incomprehensible otherness of ourfellow human beings preserves wall surfaces as a guarantee that we understand ourbounds and will store our tranquility by respecting every others"limits.

You"ve excellent a fabulous task of interpreting the poem, but Ireally don"t think Frost supposed for united state to job-related so difficult to understandhis poetry. Review the city again. View if you capture the speaker"sdispleasure at having actually to fix the wall surface every year. He"d ratherleave the alone, let the void grow. It"s his neighbor who thinks goodfences make great neighbors. Frost would be much much more likely come siton the wall and contemplate the nature roughly him. The did choose hisprivacy; if you"ve ever seen how isolated his cabin at Bread Loafis, you"ll know that. However, he likewise liked company.

See more: 2008 Chevrolet Cobalt Ss 1/4 Mile Times List, Anybody Race A Turbo Cobalt


authorized by starrkingschool.net Editorial Team

Well, the speaker doesn"t exactly want the wall down: "Something...wants that down."

The poem mirrors two neighbours coming together for the yearly rebuilding of the wall between their properties. Although the speaker seems dubious about what role the wall has, it is he who initiates the rebuilding ("I let mine neighbour know...") as well as doing irregular repairs on his own initiative ("I have come after lock and also made repair"). But he likewise dismisses the rebuilding as "just an additional kind of outdoor game." Why does the play?

I think the price is the while he might feel the wall should be unnecessary, he likewise needs to keep his neighbour in ~ a distance. He teases the man, yet is wary that him and also cannot know his clinging come "his father"s saying" about good neighbours needing great fences. Close to the end, the narrator slips into a protective tone,

I watch him thereBringing a rock grasped steady by the topIn each hand, choose an old-stone savage armed.He move in darkness as it appears to me,Not of woods only and the shade of trees

This evokes the original function of walls, native the Garden of Eden onward, to store "darkness" outside, away from human civilization.

To sum up, nature and also growth work against walls, yet the ever-present hazard from the incomprehensible otherness that our other humans preserves walls as a guarantee the we understand our bounds and also will save our tranquility by respecting every others" limits.